Ownership and Control Of Resources:

 

What is a Resource Regime?

It is a social structure or a framework within which society manages its environmental resources. The framework defines rights of access to the resource, powers to exclude others, rights of withdrawal, and rights to manage, sell and dispose of the resource.

 

Why do people strive (collectively or individually) to own and exercise control over resources?

a)               To secure the supply of food and essential resources

b)              A desire to make profits

c)               A desire to accumulate capital

d)              A desire to improve upon one’s welfare

e)               A desire to wield power over other humans

 

TYPES OF RESOURCE REGIMES

 

1. Open-Access Resource Regime

There is a free for all use of resources. Individuals and groups take whatever resources they seek from the environment. Described as having no organized regulations and mechanisms for allocating resources. Owners of property consider themselves more as “custodians” of resources that belong to the group. Right to exclude others, sell or dispose of the resource is not common.

Open access use can be sustained if demand for the resources from internal and external sources is modest.

 

2. Common Property Regimes:

No individual is privileged regarding ownership of property. It is unlike collective property regime because the collective interest has no special status regarding resource allocation Rules governing access to and control of material resources are organized on the principle that each resource is available for use by any member. Regulations are often developed to restrict use of some environmental resources to defined individuals or groups. Common property regimes are not necessarily incompatible with individual use. The extent to which commercial elements feature in common property regimes is limited although not always so.

Land is not viewed as a commodity that can be sold but rather as an inheritance that should be passed on to future generations. A group of resources are classified under common property resources – oceans, air.

 

3. Private Ownership and Property

Ownership of property is conferred on individuals. Common property regimes often give way to evolving private ownership by individuals or companies. In several parts of the world private ownership was imposed on existing common property arrangements by European Colonizers.

 

4. State or Collective Ownership

The problem of allocation is resolved on the basis of the collective interests of society as a whole. State ownership can be established by declarations at any stage of the open access to private property continuum. May be imposed because of dissatisfaction with the pattern of private ownership or if private ownership proves incapable of managing the resource in a sustainable manner. State ownership is necessary and desirable if problems of environmental resources are to be avoided or minimized.

 

Drawbacks:

a) Can lead to the breakdown of local regulatory mechanisms thereby creating a “free for all” use

b) Collective interest may be difficult to define